Request for Probation Departments: Employee Salaries and Use of Force Training Documents (Orange County)
It is a clone of this request.
| Tracking # |
R000506-042823 |
| Multi Request | Request for Probation Departments: Employee Salaries and Use of Force Training Documents |
| Submitted | March 31, 2023 |
MuckRock users can file, duplicate, track, and share public records requests like this one. Learn more.
Communications
From: Jordan Lassiter
To Whom It May Concern:
Pursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request the following records:
I am writing to request the following information:
A complete list of all employees, their job titles, and their annual salary for the last Three years (2020 and 2023).
Please provide all training documents related to the use of force within the agency, including but not limited to manuals, protocols, guidelines, and any related memos or communications.
I am making this FOIA request with any and all agencies that may have the requested information.
The purpose of this request is to gather information that will aid in a research project examining agency practices related to the use of force. The information requested will be used to assess the extent to which agency training on the use of force has been effective. This research project is being conducted as part of a larger effort to promote greater accountability and transparency within law enforcement agencies.
The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.
In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.
Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 5 business days, as the statute requires.
Sincerely,
Jordan
From: Muckrock Staff
To Whom It May Concern:
I wanted to follow up on the following New York Freedom of Information Law request, copied below, and originally submitted on April 3, 2023. Please let me know when I can expect to receive a response.
Thanks for your help, and let me know if further clarification is needed.
From: Jordan Lassiter
To Whom It May Concern:
Pursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request the following records:
I am writing to request the following information:
A complete list of all employees, their job titles, and their annual salary for the last Three years (2020 and 2023).
Please provide all training documents related to the use of force within the agency, including but not limited to manuals, protocols, guidelines, and any related memos or communications.
I am making this FOIA request with any and all agencies that may have the requested information.
The purpose of this request is to gather information that will aid in a research project examining agency practices related to the use of force. The information requested will be used to assess the extent to which agency training on the use of force has been effective. This research project is being conducted as part of a larger effort to promote greater accountability and transparency within law enforcement agencies.
The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.
In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.
Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 5 business days, as the statute requires.
Sincerely,
Jordan
From: Muckrock Staff
To Whom It May Concern:
I wanted to follow up on the following New York Freedom of Information Law request, copied below, and originally submitted on April 3, 2023. Please let me know when I can expect to receive a response.
Thanks for your help, and let me know if further clarification is needed.
From: Orange County Sheriff
Dear Jordan Jordan:
Thank you for your interest in public records of Orange County. Your request has been received and is being processed in accordance with the State of New York's Freedom of Information Law (FOIL). Your request was received in this office on 4/28/2023 and given the reference number R000506-042823 for tracking purposes. Records Requested: Subject: New York Freedom of Information Law Request: Request for Probation Departments: Employee Salaries and Use of Force Training Documents (Orange County)
To Whom It May Concern:
Pursuant to the New Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request the following records: I am writing to request the following information:
A complete list of all employees, their job titles, and their annual salary for the last three years (2020 and 2023).
Please provide all training documents related to the use of force within the agency, including but not limited to manuals, protocols, guidelines, and any related memos or communications.
I am making this FOIA request with any and all agencies that may have the requested information. The purpose of this request is to gather information that will aid in a research project examining agency practices related to use of force. Information requested will be used to assess the extent to which the agency training on the use of force has been effective. This research project is being conducted as part of a larger effort to promote greater accountability and transparency within law enforcement agencies. The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.
In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by email attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.
Your request will be forwarded to the relevant department(s) to conduct a search the records you seek and to determine the volume and any costs associated with satisfying your request. You will be contacted with a formal acknowledgement of your request in accordance with FOIL Law within five (5) business days.
PLEASE NOTE: The State of New York Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) does not require a governmental body to create new information, to do legal research, or to answer questions.
You can monitor the progress of your request at the link below and you WILL receive an email when your request has been completed. Again, thank you for using the FOIL Records Center.
Orange County
To monitor the progress or update this request please log into the FOIL Records Center (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuMbl3URICSd7vtbRg1D-2BlINFERsXSuOKRvQ8-2BWAPXakjc-3D5Qyt_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqSvC79BO5AUvyBEwnbHtyTZsgC75RtLQBvGooDPGSXLZ9KPftub2aeHRpBQzv-2FWdQ85MWd5vcdbEwpR1WA7KJsKaURXbcZIbW-2FYUrf3UwonmSZtLQ3mUWmgD2nIaBCVPO3-2F4bmflh08pe3Zd5rcqIJRPW5t8waS1aShacoue58FQ-3D)
From: Orange County
--- Please respond above this line ---
RE: COUNTY FOIL REQUEST of April 28, 2023., Reference # R000506-042823.
Dear Jordan Jordan:
This letter will serve to acknowledge receipt of your Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) Request dated April 28, 2023 pertaining to: "Subject: New York Freedom of Information Law Request: Request for Probation Departments: Employee Salaries and Use of Force Training Documents (Orange County)
To Whom It May Concern:
Pursuant to the New Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request the following records: I am writing to request the following information:
A complete list of all employees, their job titles, and their annual salary for the last three years (2020 and 2023).
Please provide all training documents related to the use of force within the agency, including but not limited to manuals, protocols, guidelines, and any related memos or communications.
I am making this FOIA request with any and all agencies that may have the requested information. The purpose of this request is to gather information that will aid in a research project examining agency practices related to use of force. Information requested will be used to assess the extent to which the agency training on the use of force has been effective. This research project is being conducted as part of a larger effort to promote greater accountability and transparency within law enforcement agencies. The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.
In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by email attachment if available or CD-ROM if not."
Please be advised that it could take up to twenty (20) business days to locate the records you seek, if indeed they are available and subject to disclosure under the Public Officers Law. We shall, of course, endeavor to have our search completed as quickly as possible.
If you have any questions or need additional information, please reply to this email.
Regards,
Tim Davidian
FOIL Officer
Probation
To monitor the progress or update this request please log into the FOIL Records Center (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM200SqCRjd8ud0hPggiziUO3gZxntVXPN-2F-2FhXkZhDebScu3Oby8GzigWLsqSgbHWzf_Aq_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqvIUfsMHZwgHO90Z9TXfeKi3NkzLzVpcqhwzecGFFGTF3s2LtVAi8cf3j7gykFhlzj9eoM9HAqxeMUdqHURnTVegXNNAejThcYlhPiZkpvF5PtalC5vXMAJht4PVSBOi4Hwut5A9pp5h2TDr7Dk-2FeIX-2B3hn66UOECTEQGquXY8mQ-3D)
From: Orange County
--- Please respond above this line ---
May 30, 2023
Jordan
MuckRock News
DEPT MR 144843
263 Huntington Avenue
Boston, MA 02115
RE: FOIL Request dated 4/26/23,
received 4/28/23
Dear Jordan:
This Department has received and reviewed your FOIL Requests captioned above.
With respect to Item #1 regarding employees, titles and annual salaries; Exhibits 1, 2, 3, and 4 are being provided in response. The summaries are filed each Spring with the New York State (NYS) Office of Probation and Correctional Alternatives (OPCA). The 2023 information (Exhibit 4) will be filed within the next 2 weeks. The summaries provide the information you are seeking, while protecting personal identifying information.
With respect to Item #2 and use of force training, all Orange County Probation Department training in these areas is conducted in accordance with NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) and the Municipal Police Training Council (MPTC) guidelines and regulations. The guidelines and regulations may be obtained directly from those agencies. With respect to Orange County Probation Department Policy, I am providing Exhibit 5, which contains pages 66 – 90 of our Policy Manual. The release of any other information, including redacted information, pertaining to Item #2 is being denied pursuant to Section 87(2)(e)(i), (iv) and (2)(f).
If you wish to apply any part of this determination, your appeal should be directed to:
Richard B. Golden, Esq., County Attorney
Orange County Department of Law
255 -275 Main Street
Goshen, NY 10924
Respectfully submitted,
Timothy A. Davidian
Probation Director
From: Jordan Lassiter
Subject: Appeal for Inadequate Disclosure of Documents Under Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)
Dear Orange County Department of Probation FOIA Appeals Officer,
I am writing to formally appeal the response to my Freedom of Information Act request (Reference No: R000506-042823) dated April 3, 2023. While I appreciate the provided documents, the response falls short of the specific information I requested.
In my original request, I specifically asked for a complete list of all employees, their job titles, and their annual salaries for the last three years (2020 to 2023), as well as training documents. The documents I received only included general job titles and salaries and did not include the requested training documents. Specific employee names and their respective salaries were omitted.
This absence of information does not satisfy the requirements of my original request. As per the Freedom of Information Law (Article 6, Sections 84-90, of the Public Officers Law), I am entitled to access this public information.
Moreover, as stated in NY Committee on Open Government Advisory Opinion, FOIL-AO-19074, "[...] records identifying public employees, their public employment history, and the salaries they receive are generally available to the public, for they are required to be maintained by an agency pursuant to law."
Therefore, I request that you reconsider your decision and provide the complete and specific information I originally requested. If the decision is upheld, I request an explanation for the reasons behind the decision, specifically detailing the FOIA exemptions applied to withhold this information.
As stipulated by the FOIA, I look forward to your response to this appeal within twenty business days (5 U.S.C. § 552(a)(6)(A)(ii)).
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
Jordan Lassiter
Independent Investigative Journalist
TransparencyReport.pw
Email: Jordan@Lassiter.eu
Phone: 1-845-748-0329
From: Orange County
A letter stating that the request appeal has been rejected.
From: Orange County
A copy of documents responsive to the request.
From: Orange County
--- Please respond above this line ---
RE: SHERIFF FOIL REQUEST of April 03, 2023., Reference # P000419-040323.
Dear Jordan Jordan,
Orange County received a FOIL request from you on April 03, 2023. Your request mentioned: "To Whom It May Concern:
Pursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request the following records:
Regarding complaints filed against the Orange County Jail in New York State for the past five years, specifically from 2019 to 2023.
I am seeking records related to any complaints made by inmates, their families, or staff members regarding the treatment of inmates, conditions of confinement, use of force by staff, and any incidents of misconduct or abuse by staff. This includes but is not limited to complaints related to:
Physical abuse or assault by staff on inmates
Use of excessive force or restraint methods
Medical neglect or mistreatment
Lack of access to necessary medications or medical care
Inadequate food, water, or hygiene conditions
Overcrowding or unsanitary conditions in living areas
Discrimination or harassment based on race, gender, sexual orientation, or religion
Violation of legal rights or due process procedures
Failure to provide necessary mental health services or support
Please provide any documents, reports, or other materials related to these complaints, including any investigation reports, disciplinary actions taken, and any corrective actions implemented by the jail.
In order to assist with my request, please provide the following information for each complaint:
Date the complaint was filed
Name of the person who filed the complaint
Nature of the complaint (i.e. use of force, medical neglect, etc.)
Any actions taken in response to the complaint
Outcome of any investigations or disciplinary proceedings related to the complaint
The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.
In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.
Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 5 business days, as the statute requires.
Sincerely,
Jordan
Upload documents directly: https://www.muckrock.com/
Please see the attached request for an extension dated May 2, 2023.
If you have any questions or need additional information, please reply to this email.
Sincerely,
Franco Miale
FOIL Officer
Jail
To monitor the progress or update this request please log into the FOIL Records Center (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM200SqCRjd8ud0hPggiziUP-2B-2BMBCaRrC5GkKOP8HuwvHut3DvaARV0pYB4Nb-2Bam8PzGX5_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLOVztuwd194bWFelT91UDQGP8eoNcRbR1ZP6tGmj82hYryWhEAo8ZLyAx5owXWpZ7cD6DxqeobiWBwjHpjEn8WU5g4SQuA8SjxjCY73kZUHVNzGyowCSq716KLg0hrllnYs2JD4b-2F3QqGoAP8dnbj0o1Zh8-2FB0j7uK6LyQ6OiH1LL-2FNAUjsz6JukxQt2HXTOhYdtt4FL-2FGWi4PxhlqtqLZeMZH62zUvw26mw9-2B8ZTEeOpwRrffgt2hcnUPS-2BffKiaLb2GbCssvObeqfOkj3mx0rphPMkZUzz2Jz14WuE5Bg929T5KYWja4qjF0AcxhWnw-3D-3D)
From: Orange County
--- Please respond above this line ---
RE: SHERIFF FOIL REQUEST of April 03, 2023., Reference # P000419-040323.
Dear Jordan Jordan,
Orange County received a FOIL request from you on April 03, 2023. Your request mentioned: "To Whom It May Concern:
Pursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request the following records:
Regarding complaints filed against the Orange County Jail in New York State for the past five years, specifically from 2019 to 2023.
I am seeking records related to any complaints made by inmates, their families, or staff members regarding the treatment of inmates, conditions of confinement, use of force by staff, and any incidents of misconduct or abuse by staff. This includes but is not limited to complaints related to:
Physical abuse or assault by staff on inmates
Use of excessive force or restraint methods
Medical neglect or mistreatment
Lack of access to necessary medications or medical care
Inadequate food, water, or hygiene conditions
Overcrowding or unsanitary conditions in living areas
Discrimination or harassment based on race, gender, sexual orientation, or religion
Violation of legal rights or due process procedures
Failure to provide necessary mental health services or support
Please provide any documents, reports, or other materials related to these complaints, including any investigation reports, disciplinary actions taken, and any corrective actions implemented by the jail.
In order to assist with my request, please provide the following information for each complaint:
Date the complaint was filed
Name of the person who filed the complaint
Nature of the complaint (i.e. use of force, medical neglect, etc.)
Any actions taken in response to the complaint
Outcome of any investigations or disciplinary proceedings related to the complaint
The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.
In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.
Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 5 business days, as the statute requires.
Sincerely,
Jordan
Upload documents directly: https://www.muckrock.com/ Please see attachments for your review.
Orange County has reviewed your request and has determined that the records requested are exempt from disclosure under FOIL for the following reasons: We do not waive other grounds of exemption by limiting our response to the above and reserve the right to assert such if this matter is appealed. Should you wish to appeal this determination, you must do so in writing submitted within thirty (30) days of the date of this letter to the attention of: Richard B. Golden, County Attorney, FOIL Appeals Officer, Orange County Department of Law, Government Center, 255-275 Main Street, Goshen, New York 10924.
If you have any questions or need additional information, please reply to this email.
Sincerely,
Franco Miale
FOIL Officer
Jail
To monitor the progress or update this request please log into the FOIL Records Center (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM200SqCRjd8ud0hPggiziUP-2B-2BMBCaRrC5GkKOP8HuwvHut3DvaARV0pYB4Nb-2Bam8PNfML_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FHkLyiHsc-2F7cOawWcnwQGQ1mGGHla0A9jln1oG2tZaiQ9wFt2OuaR4eEgOHI9sLZk4X0paXp9v-2Bl43WCjV3-2Bg50IhEEgVC3rSsuIGn3jr7TTttJq4Zodh-2FmwAdYr-2FYxdwk4Xw2yDfYtOnD7qWcR33ikq8gDohjZGJXi9AGFZitVZV3k6XHZ9vVcWuPREF3-2BOwMkSxe3iuM9V-2BhZSLKhtTpsEy1T5EodgP6sYiaDAFb-2BgF7EihYGt5nBmB3wXATblmWXiq2MVZoNUrIhQrJTlKfI-2FidEk5JPxUy-2Flol2uOfCszYB0TTx7GwZLbCCUoeFQ2g-3D-3D)
From: Orange County
Attachments:
2019_NYSCOC_COMPLAINT_105085_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGZSzx0q8c1Z3j9dlWNx5QQ7XqK4hjd0tnJWf23tgj6VIn6Dk2DC9FHU9-2Fe-2BDLkG5dQlKHoEZpf-2B-2Bo7KzzGji-2F0g-3D-3DLTuE_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0iISnpFteZtzqDqa8cJm8Mt7uaO-2FPwdMEVfvQIpOPLv0d859J0tkVLs-2FvX6ml5817QhRwtpuSdrShwK7WIfA7yxEyhFybv9ivYYhhULXQCNjz-2BXigux-2FlxmqYnUfl1-2FXYYCdoxo6sdMJlfczC-2FtyLQA-3D-3D)
2019_NYSCOC_COMPLAINT_106649_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGZSzx0q8c1Z3j9dlWNx5QQ7XqK4hjd0tnJWf23tgj6VIKl7A2Fnx0O-2FtrOwEUVQoJOtkNPGDnqZHZBq5H-2BZrHJzg-2BCq-2B5P8EJhZbrzkwxsW8-3Dn_m-_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0RijFB3eHBs2Z6TTy4c7z-2BMYt7o8Vi0s-2B1y0yilhgoI3BiADDRrcVjla6KSfgP4NkfCk1IW3EAO8n902Y9ib68IuhSpj1JSakxGtXcuEzfN3sr3F-2BqKm-2BwlkyHJ25vksNM8Bzpt15ODAe113W-2Fi1q-2FQ-3D-3D)
2019_NYSCOC_COMPLAINT_110113_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGZSzx0q8c1Z3j9dlWNx5QQ7XqK4hjd0tnJWf23tgj6VKIA9xPHYJ3DQIc7MSVfo1FLEkXRNMSWuLC9UVCJpvbmg-3D-3Dc-f7_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0AAwOUnesgwLThqdDxioHskWEV60vB2j-2Fuu-2BTWBRp6hKoRiBHA6YeOiZZkiqbn9ESxLJXTrU8dmwP7M7jS5Ud9FT-2BLtkfehnzQN0Iq2jT89lgx-2FAv2iLSrftn-2BwLOHMy4T3zyHT2gBZUkD-2BKkzK9uOw-3D-3D)
DOC040423-001.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD63mz4P-2BuypPKXdRT4N5JJLUhx2Wc64Ri2DgLZV3jLCueph83gckrrxmJaqZCOxD987sK4MKQu-2FsAU938OeO65GnYp-2BtSecvKlX1y4BydqsoA-3D-3DrqXX_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0k9SfV6S4IJTpnfgaVi15hCKR3DHw-2FY85fYQTfDVwd71hJR46qXjNtVDtomHIjqPbi6X5IMHvKaAGTJmRkw3-2BJxWLmV5NlxXKJTjV8lbLB4L4GaLgAiJi1qnA6odXWaqnZA-2BmUgsBu545v2iF-2B8q3Kw-3D-3D)
DOC050223-001.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD7Kf4rfhy5KrKWcK40r3rGDqrvLiWdZz-2BUUSUe8gln3Or-2BSnZGXse8P1RL7FYJue2v1-2BgnQ6ML9EG6yctSMh5AdubAmyhqSehvoa4bKd2IZiQ-3D-3D_tAk_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0s8nRniwZ4upzKbLY3-2BhroMHOKUj1rYaOx99-2F-2BA4wTE0MZn-2BiSAsMs5j-2FNusrD6NDMNxY3kunXRY-2BwSGG1F6EjXYKRR7Bulinwq8osEwkosOao7iGVzUp2DlltFDQVCPkdXICuZDMHmVPDab2u7n4Bw-3D-3D)
DOC080723-002.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD6FDHSQJWgoy-2BbYhJ08E6KrJABB1BdjI4f9AQgpHPwsWGFYEsLX55f5rYhoQS3v0pG1ufopvn-2BthmZ0NfIdaN9karbgDpTpOLphOV2n5IIOXw-3D-3DHML3_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0sK8KOrmdm1o7h24Y6dc4-2BJe5yCPkM-2FNCSKlWiNlznLcvqnnqxuuhO0vjhgRK-2FcTGyY92WtpZ-2BBS5f02iSQ-2FVvVRWZCNJbyqsP7ZDeCZuilJY-2BLXvBBqMPDNnhq40uOhP0PX5LsRNXu-2BqbMzTD05IzQ-3D-3D)
DOC082923-004.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGXYFr0ym9eo6-2BVAbf4SlA-2FhBhtmrH9D6RbF12fey19ra1K1PS5fuhyOaRN-2B53A5lO46hE23wejabbOunuXxi9hw-3D-3DF9no_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0swadxNFAb8BIFvHFsNisv7-2B71MLQIF54rBC0IO0j8ecFQikPFRiy4VJNkw8F-2B7cyilLwqFJHD1GCdz-2FKI1g4wqM4WkuoZ17v2uVPjZyoml1XkPDrNCvqoJQBEK5gh7FIHU7k9WVGN9VsygYA5-2Fem5w-3D-3D)
NYSCOC__117349_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGqtgC8I1KVxR0WFw9FYsyyHSdsgHhRb81FPfsiQaX9YXBnUaE0EEpRALyUXP1fcVrTtXHI4-2BB6NJPf57yRcAy-2Bg-3D-3DiZkK_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0k9nsCemeU-2FjrYypWTAzC-2BurPLdTp-2FQqpJhGzNrCGpPvhsOOTW0zxJXlfMMmkB66StQo7BbjvQeH-2BrQPGjmU29MWxZ6XMLUl4Mw3MDAFA3hmKOFfFjAMTwMT0-2BRF4h9qkVnM5D4TbMBFnw9jRPuH1DA-3D-3D)
NYSCOC__118799_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGqtgC8I1KVxR0WFw9FYsyyDy5tNaGj7ZkhSi0Zc6pBjh7Teblj-2FwMJRUl2OWz6pm-2FlY-2FqC2oEQUgWSC2LRUeHCw-3D-3DwzU1_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0e6mIzvE46KvqfSiJxVSRgbO5Gvwc0Riqp9fBURcYeFjDnm-2FzAIb2g9Tq3F7tKoLgbqKlFZomD8WtpiKG9aJzHDnCIT9G-2F0R2AvRmiUm9FL1edLH3YQEARCn0oD4IKoFJJCIS8HP9cy4rC9LwmTeLvw-3D-3D)
NYSCOC__129574_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGqtgC8I1KVxR0WFw9FYsyyDy5tNaGj7ZkhSi0Zc6pBjjAgsI0EHe2EgH5tAwmEnTfjN37IpIRzZ5vVphwPp-2FeLg-3D-3DvjKq_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0BybiRk7ri-2FXqn0oK2l88-2FHbhFQPROXSt-2BP4tv4dScTQ7rdPaRobklqywxGMuDa8pXPr3pGddMhf4mEoRGigLciEqBi4YerXzLSZeGQsDnbnWBbCOJcRmBzx63WaBhoK-2Fs-2Bw-2ByJWZ9Ai1m02v691c1A-3D-3D)
NYSCOC__130742_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGqtgC8I1KVxR0WFw9FYsyyDy5tNaGj7ZkhSi0Zc6pBjjRBDKwRvC3NIr-2BwXyzOSM6H5HHglvwVs4AgnOM6-2FXkkw-3D-3DkTW-_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0Q57-2BKWDTbJgF06MXCbCKsg-2BCVKP3wKMe66AgeLnSuOhXp6-2BnMYdED4AmWlo32twN6u0MeqelGERQn-2BI8X6Or03BNUZyBzv2U07lzp4vj5Ypdxwi6twI4-2FixMBNmwXqS7j0Jcoh6X5DD3IMlY4Gi82w-3D-3D)
NYSCOC__132029_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGqtgC8I1KVxR0WFw9FYsyyIGGvFWS-2FFeBq3zlAzbAHX9P692ROHHJOERCT0z0HoQsftwwSXseFhqFffZ8FDshaw-3D-3DF5Nh_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy03-2BaZcXGZrJyxAHGqSSiO-2FQlvm9vg-2Fv8-2FQD8D8Xnf-2BuH7Gn7040rr4xK1dTSc-2BIuHS4DPVFclPGip9abeROnHsRBRJHMrXl7NWAb97nPrxJY5-2BAYtqlp817eWU5ocml7H71TTS35G31H3RS4VhpijyQ-3D-3D)
NYSCOC__163201_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2Bpt5UsyshRL1Foe8quAxmX8NWuKqRtQLd5eJPhUA-2FCxAuct0EPpPYHjmcjiVYgAf6g-3D-3DkZXc_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0q9L9vNU30m0mI0Y9iM7MKUfC2RVCZ5kCUixuWeK4FKAsMUhYsW5CPzyi2xSTAh2XfPcF8V65HAwvbpU7-2BIxKpHzK0y0dmjpvCEi7yMshBnQ8-2FWGiKnXTs7XGl-2FQ3JOJ1w8IB7hZ-2FJsEQhTniHZB0Rg-3D-3D)
NYSCOC__166204_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2BmonUNOMcxgo1dDm9kZsgR-2F4SxY-2FNR5hwllrUmxYwICHAhgnYbPPHEFVWnj70Og-2BKQ-3D-3Dt51g_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0suiSbQGT0I-2FayT9AU-2BLh5DuwwYWFITdVjGMXEZvnHnFVYZaog7HfFtZKQ-2B-2FZZNXNebfn7n2rzprdql-2BUSUxjT83PcPe2BdI-2BSrzblsHGbfMxmbMAiUwt0QmksEGOJlAKhI0NmqqWDoK-2B-2BOjI-2FwddYg-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_153163_-_159522_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2Br6yjhqNvAbmyHy-2BZGZV7doPAvSGcZZRRTbAfOFYIg-2FRcuN7VvALl1O9TtHRbpLHb5bwBRSS15vlurgEg8Jh7A4-3DB_Wb_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0SscZx6KOMfOX5-2B321oWKWSUWl2ihPNPhwty0YIe6Q8gQxDxe1iQgkFqSIUxkH8WaBzDR51CtTDkr6WwySd9rCYIbeMsI23COD-2B6Z1ElsQZrT4UkpjIt8Tp1XsPEXGR1H92PnK6aYf0g2vsCHNb-2Bvew-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_154658_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2BqOEMXMZVcn4lsrOPwDwwEQyTGr1edVtnCAIvfRo7T7t53eqiOoHZzB1Jlcyq4GIvQ-3D-3D-qF1_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0xqNeivTtN4lgkpeO6jbdd7ueUwbPgtoUH1a2b9uSb3gZhBQDnREZwKxaZB81zzQnSgqJeq8L1x1UvFT-2FE-2BQtvA7ZqhZqZhdbjZQmxvxGBeAUodyOg0b3iartuvBuIExQLMfum89-2FtXJbf-2BIj7GIurg-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_155080_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2Bshy9USzgWitRU-2BVxrnEjlHXDlXn-2Bx-2F7VUDVQJ73Vqc7ZAmTc9dELLqiqL7aFyeJ5A-3D-3D3bqS_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0eXeq83PIJYnkQ3GP-2FO-2F8pbaIWu0SYJQldCVC1leMNOR4ivMCCkW3TGaI0-2BeNpRolrdxh3YbtnbGxIgev646aQmBed2DttXlhD2rZ5Uh9iDLmZD1fePZmn-2Fng2PplY-2BLKLRV5C0mwLBRDkBfCndKmfQ-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_159039_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2BhIKSKPQqskMbtSQI9-2FrWUpvhLA0v-2B0-2By7a-2FC4AXYF6h6QJQP1MZRX3oT7P-2Ficx1RQ-3D-3DxvMh_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0-2BOw82j6jsFfDIu87yPQ3SbkspmIz-2F9cDdAIvubHibtAE4yUnm5xEVhK9lA-2BJLd-2F5leA5QbRjDaksPpRWkkySwNYTgDCi2mD0-2BK9Qyr0QLjtatWj8r0sW-2F9dQdKkspsAlQzqlRbQh-2FJGyRyRlKxGVYA-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_159153_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2BkxMQmMLQhro3pgb-2F-2BfUuXofyYbnADPr2hvasNBd2XvWcfXbNcxH5hEBRktaSke9Dw-3D-3DTuUv_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0BJOYTF8oSl8ePQTqLD8R5f2bfaPzgatnPViqNrFOfZC6bwn5uhvY0wbbXEkuhkjm2WMo7PkulDq7htE-2Bdg98zc7lI0WNDoEfU-2BJ8FKaqHj82P1qSDCI-2BXL1eGiUb3lzfzT6g52IdTnD21pBCKZWCDA-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_160661_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2BofivmYbKS-2FC-2FEBA1-2FIr4Fn-2BEKwK-2BNh-2BDmGqfpJl-2BRUAH9FrG32aZsFsIE3hp-2B-2Bp8A-3D-3DTCAJ_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0gFwfyv5gNyUQhv0CzsCqZNVInSVpYWUonY5sSbVT-2BJ2pc-2BrPfKfEELausNOK5Ey7QdYXDwX4-2BYBZIq-2FRs68pQ1QLeLpiNglA2FabSojx1sNFMADezOFfiaQwOj9L-2FTvg6EPFjyRA8yB-2FjNFt-2BVRIhw-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_163138_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2Bv25LUKYCMh-2BeNrSxX6IFSy9CXOlKpOYDbkXInmaXyMXIEcwZNUSctWWDQ7IAFc8TQ-3D-3DaL8P_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0gBfdcOqUzbBPLLIDzdNtz9QvjZ21drtic3tQi3YV36ZHkBcU7hZVenL1FumGaDVkEKaf3JevqZO6R8Roz8dvyLYjakft7qcuK8dPegkpwFvbljnbgCJW2qIkNqrCS1rMK1PbNVoTNEyCTICk4tQI7A-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_170737_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2BhgfaUEPTSpAH7v8Q-2Fyi88HH9GzTsJhkDQcnbZfVa9OdYPpiEv0IFQ4JCZRQCtsFCg-3D-3D5u7C_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0jJ13J2EMV3uYzeI-2BnpQxIh3YucHx9jLOXs8cyM0PE2eLolYT-2FrGD1tO8vZ-2BO8582CSP-2F5MaQgKXhMwZYXh8TpjwEgEQrhKufKRkUJLAL2U-2BgvtFP0mZjIf75ONLe6d6baGMVglQc1UwVJVoB1hPDRw-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT__132312_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGhEserpecZtw9kLsoZ5cfLWRNChlNAsEOB883tIOY2WbtRVRVqbq278kTpzCY6B7RELSwyarplcsASixpphNyKg-3D-3DynuL_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0OiYVA6yEN29tdOWoUYs-2FjjY2JNq9oTfR4Gf9XPQ2-2FF-2BcUFyK7lD1ZkWw3LtReTUvmgGb8FEfAkzIOqDVz3nTHF6stuxiK2ubFFsOL9waSeVnOaWmxutO3kBJrWxjvph5rF5HmCjhPx5Yt1VAlO7bMQ-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT__134395_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGhEserpecZtw9kLsoZ5cfLQBYiWXek-2F1-2FhLTruVWlLONsJHa0MJarmRMoZ9Z5JhI92io38-2BYFA-2BCM8NUWvjEM-2Fw-3D-3DoZsI_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0DazOBKbQ-2B-2BV0h-2FiC-2BIO-2BAC4ZnGFg6k85ED30t5b4GuD9-2BrNatkx6oGqvwnh-2FCB9uaD4EUbW5S2aYqYAVngQ1AoGTOz9joEtR2G2Mt3KU863ndbUWWgNe-2BtPBGWORlW-2FakXDr4rCNHfNxhJessScTyQ-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT__142900__144582_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGhEserpecZtw9kLsoZ5cfLaonDI5NnWZxNxzW5BA-2BR7UL-2B666IH5k1GqNf-2BFdaxjm8RzsFz0SdreryUpk7Jjz0g-3D-3D2776_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy05TzygIl0WfQinM5P-2FvyVp5iJATAkUHmzXDDafHcsHnMYyn85GxwEneXQmcrfmTxlmmAE9a1FL48zaUPzxm-2BiVqb-2BIG0E77NIoNZV54yJX-2FVP-2BrZg8KFJe1y6aUBlzfu9mvsiHVEhQb16YqxI5iJj-2BQ-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT__15066_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGhEserpecZtw9kLsoZ5cfLXVIN2hiRk9cofmiGm5iDCNPtp9YMTsGF2CGjvL8WCXESBpWADrQRHGi0jzqmQ1ePA-3D-3DHbe6_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0O-2BYPYcRmF9Avp1-2BZfSk1FPGTn0PXHhJLSfBbPhgEWxGX9iAqdYnkEN65s4wYWEIIA7eiD5Nb5tXI3yv7b175pbJX2ES3cWjSC6-2BnamLYNBAb-2FoW2h7P81kiwo5BIZJhlxXa8YOBpMVpJ2fgY8YPwgw-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT__172820_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2Bl0YRjQIT28T1XojNaQjDXFxX3nQr4LeyV9GvGkQavnvmJbE-2FoSOcytk07irmOwCFw-3D-3DVOrm_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0LO5dyMczss0BrLOf84cx0be29zBYcanPman26sAJhBkGzbVbwZe-2FsxD3k7ToT8ifozzPCemPI9DOoUMdrw8-2BdYeD1a-2F-2FLDajifjpXRfBZ2LTYhY4gaJEBUTQ5e-2FbgVEz7Ixh2yaayhtkzpJSr-2BYH9Q-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT__173396_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGKqiNmYr4bzSR3o5S55HA-2BpJQ7HY-2BbGZ-2FHqkrf3cQnBKurH5-2Bj2pIK9TFaXwOmNqsDXjK2e0vQANUkd5OoH03lQ-3D-3DQul1_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0Wvlt-2BMTxI98s9HSrGKwMM4KhdIVpKQ2IxM04ob22csqfyysfky82pMS2NvzjsNYJR7w6BLkThh46r1BLtfbVSrnUK0taAfb9OvtBEz2UllroXe-2F03Iz1BTO8NFhlIjUMqfVZ1k5NH07rcJmepdRB5g-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT_148267_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGhEserpecZtw9kLsoZ5cfLUyvKi0jlPSbNKMVTQ2DlVQwKO2K4i2wAJa73DiJ-2BypM921L13-2FTm6hyoMVmbVT-2FeQ-3D-3DjN9F_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0mH3-2FESinw-2BqnED3iqk7SnNh-2FLfCOnerW0og2Jv7HPr2uQs-2BFhgH7gIw79ys1Rr3GyieSOHB6kh8PqhpU3XpoKu5KBAQsym96Y4prDX5nRplfJgpptI6yjtRD5cX-2BLqLyHce3ZPpOsIfbxrWECfuzLQ-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT_-MO_MC_CARTHY_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGqtgC8I1KVxR0WFw9FYsyyADUsqaFwGdnN-2FdWjUKKVIL9mURDaq90ryu9F-2BwboZnJJG4f069PDCMA53TiCvyoTA-3D-3Db732_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0ckkn8w5-2BXM-2FOECLH3zSHZygbJ0Bb3qUEYOqTkt-2Ba9892WMFJfMtk2AqbemIadubr9znzDCQoGTKDUQOMuOhCoCLjCRTeYKucnj1HXsg-2FFioUmDYTxe203IJN5ckjyEemTXPtoc0q7jjvqFM5vuTxnw-3D-3D)
NYSCOC_COMPLAINT_-THOMAS_A_redacted.pdf (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM7uqmOh84phGvx1cllHnP1KvKnayOPPIIZj0mElfQWD4KRi0rFnIzWXUjrIt2xvCGqtgC8I1KVxR0WFw9FYsyyKA2hcv8YFlwSobC1ZyvLC1leYGYcjLT1GEf-2FGRS7foxUrT9-2Bao8naiy8vioZlW48w-3D-3Dey6v_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0mr1NE669ejTOAJ6JeVsL1cAnPtGlwyJ4bJrYCHYB8VoImLT6n6VOW-2B6-2B7GbODyO7YosdaDWxkOd5WySGxEyZAJng-2FxmsS1GH3f26bcHufEc2ZNlk-2Fkfj8oB5ZArRpR3apeQh1VOamSW8MPcGX1uVmQ-3D-3D)
--- Please respond above this line ---
RE: SHERIFF FOIL REQUEST of April 03, 2023., Reference # P000419-040323.
Dear Jordan Jordan,
Orange County received a FOIL request from you on April 03, 2023. Your request mentioned: "To Whom It May Concern:
Pursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, I hereby request the following records:
Regarding complaints filed against the Orange County Jail in New York State for the past five years, specifically from 2019 to 2023.
I am seeking records related to any complaints made by inmates, their families, or staff members regarding the treatment of inmates, conditions of confinement, use of force by staff, and any incidents of misconduct or abuse by staff. This includes but is not limited to complaints related to:
Physical abuse or assault by staff on inmates
Use of excessive force or restraint methods
Medical neglect or mistreatment
Lack of access to necessary medications or medical care
Inadequate food, water, or hygiene conditions
Overcrowding or unsanitary conditions in living areas
Discrimination or harassment based on race, gender, sexual orientation, or religion
Violation of legal rights or due process procedures
Failure to provide necessary mental health services or support
Please provide any documents, reports, or other materials related to these complaints, including any investigation reports, disciplinary actions taken, and any corrective actions implemented by the jail.
In order to assist with my request, please provide the following information for each complaint:
Date the complaint was filed
Name of the person who filed the complaint
Nature of the complaint (i.e. use of force, medical neglect, etc.)
Any actions taken in response to the complaint
Outcome of any investigations or disciplinary proceedings related to the complaint
The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.
In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.
Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 5 business days, as the statute requires.
Sincerely,
Jordan
Upload documents directly: https://www.muckrock.com/
Orange County has reviewed your request and has determined that the records requested are exempt from disclosure under FOIL for the following reasons: We do not waive other grounds of exemption by limiting our response to the above and reserve the right to assert such if this matter is appealed. Should you wish to appeal this determination, you must do so in writing submitted within thirty (30) days of the date of this letter to the attention of: Richard B. Golden, County Attorney, FOIL Appeals Officer, Orange County Department of Law, Government Center, 255-275 Main Street, Goshen, New York 10924.
If you have any questions or need additional information, please reply to this email.
Sincerely,
Franco Miale
FOIL Officer
Jail
To monitor the progress or update this request please log into the FOIL Records Center (https://u8387778.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=6HtRfOYLt5fXvpttM-2FU1HSHl8-2BXrH0Emh1YnwY6awN482QiDeqX8ID9nRC-2BxKUuM200SqCRjd8ud0hPggiziUP-2B-2BMBCaRrC5GkKOP8HuwvHut3DvaARV0pYB4Nb-2Bam8PVQBz_L6oZ1hthide01sczOvz6e5kURLFR-2FRYnNCrL9QhFlxwjA4WLXVFDXDnQ8k2D-2FuPqa1lEIUfhvdbgym-2BO94zO-2FLcOrY872vumiuhegWfw4ClkfmixMCBueyKLSYIv1Sy9vtdumH24CgL23XncCVibD2O-2BPJBrDyc90yIYKDRjF1zI2nqOfVPlPtM1Wf-2F5jkKMMXceNpQPYviSlW-2BCubJVRVoismkHF-2FjMaqlwSvRZHesGi71GE38iey-2F1URnVYzy0cylOHad55mvXc7bRHZDYSfrspHJPM3kHvweqOOkDyzK15-2BrzJM1blXtkcAz-2FoVzWrMSuxZvTeuARYKV5j2rpH2LK5IjlKb3wWhO11qV120zYGRZ0MpXwO57TKQcm6ZsHLtSHNCWxa9a4fPpdoz9h5w-3D-3D)
Files
pages