Rounding up emails from paid activists

Mary Mangan filed this request with the University of California, Berkeley of California.
Due April 12, 2023
Est. Completion None
Status
Awaiting Response

Communications

From: Mary Mangan


To Whom It May Concern:

Pursuant to the California Public Records Act, I hereby request the following records:

Please provide any emails to or from Elena Conis associated with the book "Whitewash" itself, or "Los Angeles Review of Books" review of "Whitewash" by Carey Gillam, "Rounding Up the Risks of Big Ag". In addition, include any emails with any of these words or people: glyphosate, herbicide, IARC, Monsanto, Carey Gillam, Whitewash, Island Press, any employee of Island Press (@islandpress.org), any employee of US Right to Know (@usrtk.org), Gary Ruskin, Carey Gillam, Stacy Malkan, Becky Morrison, Paul Thacker, any employee of LA Review of Books (@lareviewofbooks.org). The time frame of the search should be from October 2017 through the end of May 2018.

The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and this request is not being made for commercial purposes.

In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.

Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 10 calendar days, as the statute requires.

Sincerely,

Mary Mangan

From: University of California, Berkeley

Dear Ms. Mangan:

This is to acknowledge your California Public Records Act (CPRA) request
below. Your request has been forwarded to appropriate campus offices and a
search for responsive documents is currently underway. Records identified
as responsive to your request will be reviewed, and made available for your
access, in accordance with relevant law and University policy.

Please note that there is no central repository for all University records.
The identification and collection of potentially responsive records is only
the first step in the CPRA response process. The collected records must be
reviewed by this office to ensure that they are in fact responsive to your
request and to assess whether any legal privileges or exemptions from
disclosure are applicable and whether redactions may be required to protect
individuals’ rights to privacy. Please also bear in mind that we are
concurrently fulfilling numerous other requests, many of which were
received before yours and that we generally process requests in the order
in which they are received. The current timeframe for fulfillment of most
requests is 8 weeks, although this may vary due to the nature and
complexity of the request.

Although the requested records have not yet been fully identified, based on
the terms of the request, we have made a preliminary determination that the
request likely does seek disclosable records within the possession of the
University. This office will provide you with a status update after the
requested records have been thoroughly reviewed.

Please note that CPRA allows agencies to make records available “upon
payment of fees covering direct costs of duplication.” Government Code
section 6253(b). The University reserves its right to recoup duplication
costs. The charge is $0.20 per page for copies, and payment is required
before release of the records. Once we obtain an accurate page count, we
will inform you of the anticipated total cost.

Regards,

Liane Ko
Public Records Coordinator

************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: <
​​
requests@muckrock.com>
Date: Tue, May 15, 2018 at 12:07 PM
Subject: California Public Records Act Request: Rounding up emails from
paid activists
To: pra@berkeley.edu

University of California, Berkeley
PRA Office
MC #1500
200 California Hall
Berkeley, CA 94720-1500

May 15, 2018

To Whom It May Concern:

Pursuant to the California Public Records Act, I hereby request the
following records:

Please provide any emails to or from
​​
Elena Conis associated with the book "Whitewash" itself, or "Los Angeles
Review of Books" review of "Whitewash" by Carey Gillam, "Rounding Up the
Risks of Big Ag". In addition, include any emails with any of these words
or people: glyphosate, herbicide, IARC, Monsanto, Carey Gillam, Whitewash,
Island Press, any employee of Island Press (@islandpress.org), any employee
of US Right to Know (@usrtk.org), Gary Ruskin, Carey Gillam, Stacy Malkan,
Becky Morrison, Paul Thacker, any employee of LA Review of Books (@
lareviewofbooks.org). The time frame of the search should be from October
2017 through the end of May 2018.

The requested documents will be made available to the general public, and
this request is not being made for commercial purposes.

In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform
me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer
the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or
CD-ROM if not.

Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I
look forward to receiving your response to this request within 10 calendar
days, as the statute requires.

Sincerely,

Mary Mangan

Filed via MuckRock.com
E-mail (Preferred): requests@muckrock.com
Upload documents directly: https://www.muckrock.com/accounts/agency_login/
university-of-california-berkeley-3123/rounding-up-
emails-from-paid-activists-53895/?uuid-login=f61f808a-
0121-4af5-9308-091b50029e6e&email=pra%40berkeley.edu#agency-reply
Is this email coming to the wrong contact? Something else wrong? Use the
above link to let us know.

For mailed responses, please address (see note):
MuckRock News
DEPT MR 53895
411A Highland Ave
<https://maps.google.com/?q=411A+Highland+Ave+Somerville,+MA+02144&entry=gmail&source=g>
Somerville, MA 02144
<https://maps.google.com/?q=411A+Highland+Ave+Somerville,+MA+02144&entry=gmail&source=g>
-2516

PLEASE NOTE: This request is not filed by a MuckRock staff member, but is
being sent through MuckRock by the above in order to better track, share,
and manage public records requests. Also note that improperly addressed
(i.e., with the requester's name rather than "MuckRock News" and the
department number) requests might be returned as undeliverable.

From: University of California, Berkeley

Dear Ms. Mangan:

Your request is in line for processing. Please understand that UC Berkeley
receives a high volume of requests and inquires for public records and that
there is one staff person responsible for collecting, reviewing and
preparing records for release. As a result, fulfilling requests can take
some time.

Thank you for your continued patience.
Regards,

Liane Ko

Public Records Coordinator

************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley

From: University of California, Berkeley

Dear Ms. Mangan:

Your request is in line for processing. Please understand that UC Berkeley
receives a high volume of requests and inquires for public records and that
there is one staff person responsible for collecting, reviewing and
preparing records for release. As a result, fulfilling requests can take
some time.

Thank you for your continued patience.
Regards,

Liane Wong
Public Records Coordinator
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley

From:

This email acknowledges your Public Record Act
request. Please note that the Coronavirus and
associated preventative steps (e.g. office closures and/or non-essential UC staff to work remotely) are affecting our office’s ability to obtain and review
responsive records as quickly as usual. Our estimated date of production for
all new requests is ten weeks, although we are sometimes able to provide
records in a shorter timeframe. Thank you for your patience during this time.
We will be in contact with you as soon as practicable regarding your request.
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley
--
Regards,
Liane Wong
Public Records Coordinator
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley

From: Mary Mangan

Dear Liane Wong,

I appreciate your optimistic estimate of 10 weeks. Can you explain why this has been in your queue for 2 years now?

Thanks.

Mary

From:

This email acknowledges your Public Record Act
request. Please note that the Coronavirus and
associated preventative steps (e.g. office closures and/or non-essential UC staff working remotely) are affecting our office’s ability to obtain and review
responsive records as quickly as usual. Our estimated date of production for
all new requests is ten weeks, although we are sometimes able to provide
records in a shorter timeframe. Thank you for your patience during this time.
We will be in contact with you as soon as practicable regarding your request.
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley
--
Regards,
Liane Wong
Public Records Coordinator
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley

From:

This email acknowledges your Public Record Act
request. Please note that the Coronavirus and
associated preventative steps (e.g. office closures and/or non-essential UC staff working remotely) are affecting our office’s ability to obtain and review
responsive records as quickly as usual. Our estimated date of production for
all new requests is ten weeks, although we are sometimes able to provide
records in a shorter timeframe. Thank you for your patience during this time.
We will be in contact with you as soon as practicable regarding your request.
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley
--
Regards,
Liane Wong
Public Records Coordinator
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley

From: University of California, Berkeley

Dear Ms. Mangan:

This is a further response to your California Public Records Act (CPRA)
request. We sincerely apologize for the length of time it has taken to
fulfill your records request, and want to assure you that University has no
intention to purposely delay in responding to your request. We are
releasing the non-exempt documents. Due to the size of these files, you
will be receiving a separate email invitation from Box to access these
documents.

We withheld information regarding individuals to protect their privacy
pursuant to Government Code Section 6254(c). Government Code section
6255 provides
that the University may withhold any record if, on the facts of the
particular case, the public interest served by not disclosing the record
clearly outweighs the public interest served by disclosure of the record.
Consistent with that provision, the University has sought to protect
against the disclosure of records related to research projects that have
not yet been published. We withheld student information and identifying
information. Students' right to privacy is protected under federal and
state laws, including the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FEPRA)
(34 CFR 99.31) and the Information Practices Act (IPA) (Civil Code section
1798.24), which are both incorporated into the California Public Records
Act pursuant to Government Code section 6254(k). Students' right to
privacy is also protected under Government Code section 6254(c).
Regards,
Liane Wong
Public Records Coordinator
************************************
Public Records Office
University of California, Berkeley

From:

Liane Wong has invited you to collaborate on a folder:
"I'd like to share my files with you on Box." – Liane Wong
Collaborated Folder
Accept Invite: https://berkeley.account.box.com/signup/collab/vmpahgqmiv?utm_source=trans&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_campaign=collab%2Binvite%20new%20user
Get our app to view this on mobile
our app: https://app.box.com/link/?lp=mOYQ-PtoQwGDmylLtRp0nsZnINsrI3w6bFXD9QQVHKQFgOAlDnH_t4trkY6CNUlZ0uCxFokT8gvYjqvDCiRASvkHykvViEtORVHP6FqvpXpLVeFsWCpv2Qpp28GniS6pM_Txzz2oqkTBuzBOOlbXlDI5G41qgC59pW1_Eld4Of8XIlcrB_3BuV4Q9iPe8O5xLeyzgWQSePTexFUvk7KA1bw924H28Z5QJXRvnd1WU71uBepZUBohnGYUv65Jp-RkXqDkcfYirm8BYn9x_1jm7KpgOrWElndFY84LusXlbCsiC3K-q6Z4EVfM9M-o8dqqV8pbNAKJSt3lW6Xbp0tzh93QxL2PPi1ROfNA3hjCrpu2GwK_sNECbGGIIVbRIiuh4fBoIm82mf4BLIV9dTzvbgNs7Zx7XI2IQw..&a=click&tt=GetMobileApp&ru=DHDHJL0kapzSgTX7qvY6cj6PwdW4vlU5Mcclyaz-_bqmdER8wqk2cvX2k8LXReBPv-wMJVJfJSvvNT4fwfMqYJZ3NRV8e8ClGs2cSFoIvE4ELINNhH77oM5ocUWeEFUobybt3Cv3jfgf45BwQcM0rK8Uc2xST6uZua5s5xqXo08.
© 2020
https://www.box.com/link/?lp=mOYQ-PtoQwGDmylLtRp0nsZnINsrI3w6bFXD9QQVHKQFgOAlDnH_t4trkY6CNUlZ0uCxFokT8gvYjqvDCiRASvkHykvViEtORVHP6FqvpXpLVeFsWCpv2Qpp28GniS6pM_Txzz2oqkTBuzBOOlbXlDI5G41qgC59pW1_Eld4Of8XIlcrB_3BuV4Q9iPe8O5xLeyzgWQSePTexFUvk7KA1bw924H28Z5QJXRvnd1WU71uBepZUBohnGYUv65Jp-RkXqDkcfYirm8BYn9x_1jm7KpgOrWElndFY84LusXlbCsiC3K-q6Z4EVfM9M-o8dqqV8pbNAKJSt3lW6Xbp0tzh93QxL2PPi1ROfNA3hjCrpu2GwK_sNECbGGIIVbRIiuh4fBoIm82mf4BLIV9dTzvbgNs7Zx7XI2IQw..&a=click&tt=BoxImage&ru=9YKUyQq0E0IVBwTfBv1h6MAwdOScNMc4zXAj2C-vSuPaAqTP1d5NLd_hIjm8Ym6KZ9981JesKXBvH7zzm7KNyc4wqLokLM-s1E5JgLWgSjLHqforP0JZ2fB6
About Box • Privacy Policy • Edit Notification Settings • 900 Jefferson Avenue, Redwood City, CA 94063, USA
About Box: https://www.box.com/link/?lp=mOYQ-PtoQwGDmylLtRp0nsZnINsrI3w6bFXD9QQVHKQFgOAlDnH_t4trkY6CNUlZ0uCxFokT8gvYjqvDCiRASvkHykvViEtORVHP6FqvpXpLVeFsWCpv2Qpp28GniS6pM_Txzz2oqkTBuzBOOlbXlDI5G41qgC59pW1_Eld4Of8XIlcrB_3BuV4Q9iPe8O5xLeyzgWQSePTexFUvk7KA1bw924H28Z5QJXRvnd1WU71uBepZUBohnGYUv65Jp-RkXqDkcfYirm8BYn9x_1jm7KpgOrWElndFY84LusXlbCsiC3K-q6Z4EVfM9M-o8dqqV8pbNAKJSt3lW6Xbp0tzh93QxL2PPi1ROfNA3hjCrpu2GwK_sNECbGGIIVbRIiuh4fBoIm82mf4BLIV9dTzvbgNs7Zx7XI2IQw..&a=click&tt=AboutBox&ru=2LZyYPMkIaBTAOh_ZdB06wtrrcI4lzn9V56x-pjhH30Z0NeorZOHZ0iZxxqXu3PCaKLbETYRt76Z-QlhVIu9eqB2kk6b4XT__RswEy7G0tUU-MUFQCLrtDFVfh82VSp-R4P79A..
Privacy Policy: https://app.box.com/link/?lp=mOYQ-PtoQwGDmylLtRp0nsZnINsrI3w6bFXD9QQVHKQFgOAlDnH_t4trkY6CNUlZ0uCxFokT8gvYjqvDCiRASvkHykvViEtORVHP6FqvpXpLVeFsWCpv2Qpp28GniS6pM_Txzz2oqkTBuzBOOlbXlDI5G41qgC59pW1_Eld4Of8XIlcrB_3BuV4Q9iPe8O5xLeyzgWQSePTexFUvk7KA1bw924H28Z5QJXRvnd1WU71uBepZUBohnGYUv65Jp-RkXqDkcfYirm8BYn9x_1jm7KpgOrWElndFY84LusXlbCsiC3K-q6Z4EVfM9M-o8dqqV8pbNAKJSt3lW6Xbp0tzh93QxL2PPi1ROfNA3hjCrpu2GwK_sNECbGGIIVbRIiuh4fBoIm82mf4BLIV9dTzvbgNs7Zx7XI2IQw..&a=click&tt=PrivacyPolicy&ru=okN6k4FZRNgZr_bu9IHyd2lYnVQMubhbbfUepMiyOGHZD3gXvq7mEW0DKpjSy8ei7_MvPB5GpUZhnRYlovW5cldhddf3BmXKct0rFqQM-UKxZwJhFqhtYrbxipBr70Ag8iEmERa30wZb6k83jZn_c-ML7Hc.
Edit Notification Settings: https://app.box.com/link/?lp=mOYQ-PtoQwGDmylLtRp0nsZnINsrI3w6bFXD9QQVHKQFgOAlDnH_t4trkY6CNUlZ0uCxFokT8gvYjqvDCiRASvkHykvViEtORVHP6FqvpXpLVeFsWCpv2Qpp28GniS6pM_Txzz2oqkTBuzBOOlbXlDI5G41qgC59pW1_Eld4Of8XIlcrB_3BuV4Q9iPe8O5xLeyzgWQSePTexFUvk7KA1bw924H28Z5QJXRvnd1WU71uBepZUBohnGYUv65Jp-RkXqDkcfYirm8BYn9x_1jm7KpgOrWElndFY84LusXlbCsiC3K-q6Z4EVfM9M-o8dqqV8pbNAKJSt3lW6Xbp0tzh93QxL2PPi1ROfNA3hjCrpu2GwK_sNECbGGIIVbRIiuh4fBoIm82mf4BLIV9dTzvbgNs7Zx7XI2IQw..&a=click&tt=EditNotificationSettings&ru=t-vk8nNRCpDd2crvxNx5io5aNVg6e7sDrfC38Q4Dn1W921lCiK2S4bdnnF7R-hTQHioouQrA9w0ZREqOFOF8ZsBffWEIE6KHKGdcH2P0Uzj5u101HaR2pQGEJ9CfOG3CvmGKIOyL6e4JkARM20blgg..
To unsubscribe from these emails please click the following link:

From: University of California, Berkeley

Liane Wong has invited you to collaborate on a folder:
Reminder: Liane Wong is waiting for your reply.
Collaborated Folder
Accept Invite: https://berkeley.account.box.com/signup/collab/vmpahgqmiv?utm_source=trans&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_campaign=collab%2Binvite%20new%20user
Get our app to view this on mobile
our app: https://app.box.com/link/?lp=XwJQ1ELfptuPngcme4yTtrB7Y9wKUZkYO3B7nWElsLhXtIi3ef6PBXlzhBWZaIZk3SDgOJM4anxzGpNxui-9rmRLkftRLG73DAqQlPPEc4CbT4xWpNRxKnz0ERlYC862-nlfSC9HfAUmSvnlPOtrCQZz_60EABbJuVPwb1mT2t5Mo0ubjl8vK4UUnlQohGY_STW-3O--1vZZ98V2FUBRoYbAyK2j1U3ze6atCqEG3_Bq1Aq2KgIyc9cLELrMDpLj3jcJPQpZ19FKdA9CTKqkAmw955U5hBq3zrHC4O2ehBjmNYlg4_GHixvqzHsHwyIGV5n1za81XDj-9ANkkPormIcL1EmT_Qje5RUx3Od-Dc8flrAXozU8n0nou19pwZJu9t7GqQso8FRSpjTqg98cI3TC66y1PLqnXQ..&a=click&tt=GetMobileApp&ru=LCr31rnWVKItXz2_EmkcsYO3GjkpTC1Ez7o9F6YqGdwz-1-ysuFYKXAYqeVYC8tgqdbJcoNCeA1mt-IzvNCJw5AqcVHI0UOuWIh9huWZ0bTtQzmhcWfVlPeYsAPDAlkjwAazfpMIRjVDHQKG15KaBMb3SiQ_5tFSn9DwKdy5mtY.
© 2020
https://www.box.com/link/?lp=XwJQ1ELfptuPngcme4yTtrB7Y9wKUZkYO3B7nWElsLhXtIi3ef6PBXlzhBWZaIZk3SDgOJM4anxzGpNxui-9rmRLkftRLG73DAqQlPPEc4CbT4xWpNRxKnz0ERlYC862-nlfSC9HfAUmSvnlPOtrCQZz_60EABbJuVPwb1mT2t5Mo0ubjl8vK4UUnlQohGY_STW-3O--1vZZ98V2FUBRoYbAyK2j1U3ze6atCqEG3_Bq1Aq2KgIyc9cLELrMDpLj3jcJPQpZ19FKdA9CTKqkAmw955U5hBq3zrHC4O2ehBjmNYlg4_GHixvqzHsHwyIGV5n1za81XDj-9ANkkPormIcL1EmT_Qje5RUx3Od-Dc8flrAXozU8n0nou19pwZJu9t7GqQso8FRSpjTqg98cI3TC66y1PLqnXQ..&a=click&tt=BoxImage&ru=urQb3m348Tsu499bKCT_yUsIApD3GTPVyASNrm2B1Cl9yYirBYxTMK7LOHUdN17Lzo34D8wS42pV1gNfH4QDL4Fv5uOa7ChUA-88HZRj9fYWmLxMqd_xBeL5
About Box • Privacy Policy • Edit Notification Settings • 900 Jefferson Avenue, Redwood City, CA 94063, USA
About Box: https://www.box.com/link/?lp=XwJQ1ELfptuPngcme4yTtrB7Y9wKUZkYO3B7nWElsLhXtIi3ef6PBXlzhBWZaIZk3SDgOJM4anxzGpNxui-9rmRLkftRLG73DAqQlPPEc4CbT4xWpNRxKnz0ERlYC862-nlfSC9HfAUmSvnlPOtrCQZz_60EABbJuVPwb1mT2t5Mo0ubjl8vK4UUnlQohGY_STW-3O--1vZZ98V2FUBRoYbAyK2j1U3ze6atCqEG3_Bq1Aq2KgIyc9cLELrMDpLj3jcJPQpZ19FKdA9CTKqkAmw955U5hBq3zrHC4O2ehBjmNYlg4_GHixvqzHsHwyIGV5n1za81XDj-9ANkkPormIcL1EmT_Qje5RUx3Od-Dc8flrAXozU8n0nou19pwZJu9t7GqQso8FRSpjTqg98cI3TC66y1PLqnXQ..&a=click&tt=AboutBox&ru=TtEjqR9nt2RAv7MUtXgsg2nlped-1MdWsvaFHS1qfvH5KPB1lAB1fxl3e1G4K6fn5pWDDkMv66_KmnGBEV_I3beOQjrdWirYe1C0I2fk8jecMAq5yGA_ypHMMkRugf_-VWCXtQ..
Privacy Policy: https://app.box.com/link/?lp=XwJQ1ELfptuPngcme4yTtrB7Y9wKUZkYO3B7nWElsLhXtIi3ef6PBXlzhBWZaIZk3SDgOJM4anxzGpNxui-9rmRLkftRLG73DAqQlPPEc4CbT4xWpNRxKnz0ERlYC862-nlfSC9HfAUmSvnlPOtrCQZz_60EABbJuVPwb1mT2t5Mo0ubjl8vK4UUnlQohGY_STW-3O--1vZZ98V2FUBRoYbAyK2j1U3ze6atCqEG3_Bq1Aq2KgIyc9cLELrMDpLj3jcJPQpZ19FKdA9CTKqkAmw955U5hBq3zrHC4O2ehBjmNYlg4_GHixvqzHsHwyIGV5n1za81XDj-9ANkkPormIcL1EmT_Qje5RUx3Od-Dc8flrAXozU8n0nou19pwZJu9t7GqQso8FRSpjTqg98cI3TC66y1PLqnXQ..&a=click&tt=PrivacyPolicy&ru=l5iAeuS6JFn1z6N2qKJ9JLqtX-bPmdck0Cv2qSgEfE6HliItgqn-3QUSIeCwMdkkKMxDvr5nq-vXbYAlo6x16njViYcsXQA_9xqs6qFtF5gIjdAZqT5cMAfU3BCTTCisUUtUddeeQUYv2uCYEcjI4fLeaPg.
Edit Notification Settings: https://app.box.com/link/?lp=XwJQ1ELfptuPngcme4yTtrB7Y9wKUZkYO3B7nWElsLhXtIi3ef6PBXlzhBWZaIZk3SDgOJM4anxzGpNxui-9rmRLkftRLG73DAqQlPPEc4CbT4xWpNRxKnz0ERlYC862-nlfSC9HfAUmSvnlPOtrCQZz_60EABbJuVPwb1mT2t5Mo0ubjl8vK4UUnlQohGY_STW-3O--1vZZ98V2FUBRoYbAyK2j1U3ze6atCqEG3_Bq1Aq2KgIyc9cLELrMDpLj3jcJPQpZ19FKdA9CTKqkAmw955U5hBq3zrHC4O2ehBjmNYlg4_GHixvqzHsHwyIGV5n1za81XDj-9ANkkPormIcL1EmT_Qje5RUx3Od-Dc8flrAXozU8n0nou19pwZJu9t7GqQso8FRSpjTqg98cI3TC66y1PLqnXQ..&a=click&tt=EditNotificationSettings&ru=6XG8UGDyohxqVxo19sShRbV3EYAGN5RAMtrBAmrj2BcyOVlLX0uMZ14qf5fStpydAINY2sniOsVUzz3PyJw7BkxCK4T82AeMlDAPMfOHg79xZEpeAF1xKV9RyvckfdhSzHt1-yuNZtIVCAJGeThW8w..
To unsubscribe from these emails please click the following link:

From: Mary Mangan

Thanks to Liane Wong for finally delivering these documents, more than 2 years since the request was made.

It's not clear to me if others can access this file. But I have downloaded a copy.

The undisclosed conflict of interest, the ghostwriting by paid activists, and other email was very informative.

Best regards,

Mary Mangan

PS: I used to be opposed to FOIAs of this kind, but Paul Thacker and Charle Seife have convinced me that this is my duty. https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-0821-seife-thacker-science-transparency-20150821-story.html And you can thank US Right to Know for setting this all in motion.

Files

There are no files associated with this request.