ADL's Involvement in Boston CVE Programs (Boston Public Schools)

Jonathan Brown filed this request with the Boston Public Schools of Boston, MA.
Multi Request ADL's Involvement in Boston CVE Programs
Status
Completed

Communications

From: Jonathan Brown


To Whom It May Concern:

Pursuant to the Massachusetts Public Records Law, I hereby request the following records:

Background: reports by the US Attorney's Office District of Massachusetts and RAND Corporation, as well as public records obtained by the Muslim Justice League, list the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) as an official partner* in three Countering Violent Extremism (CVE) programs developed and implemented in Boston and Massachusetts, also known as "Youth and Police Initiative Plus (YPIP)", "New Freedoms Intervention", "Empower Peace" (with its campaign "Online4Good"), as well as a 2015 Greater Boston framework for CVE. Also listed as partners in these programs are numerous public entities beholden to state and national public records laws, including Boston Public Schools, Massachusetts Executive Office of Health and Human Services, Boston Police Department, Cambridge Police Department, FEMA, Massachusetts Department of Correction, Executive Office of Public Safety and Security of Massachusetts, US Attorney's Office for the District of Massachusetts, and the Massachusetts Office of Grants and Research. I request records detailing the nature, extent, and results of ADL's involvement in regards to these programs and any and all other similar ones, as follows:

*[Links: https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/usao-ma/pages/attachments/2015/02/18/framework.pdf
https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/RR2600/RR2647/RAND_RR2647.pdf
https://www.muslimjusticeleague.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/MA-PEACE-Project-FFY17-Q2-report-3-31-17-final-5.pdf
https://www.muslimjusticeleague.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/MA-PEACE-Project-FFY17-Q3-report-6.26.17-10.pdf]

1) Any and all records or documents created with, mentioning, provided by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs, reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the domain “@adl.org” including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “osegal@adl.org”), presentations, slides, transactions, training materials, consultations, curricula, etc., for the sake of preventing:
-“violent extremism”
-“terrorism”
-“radicalization”
-“incitement”
-“hate speech”
-“hate crimes”
[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record fulfillment)]

2) Any and all records or documents created with/by, mentioning, provided by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs, reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the domain “@adl.org” including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “osegal@adl.org”), presentations, slides, transactions, training materials, consultations, curricula, etc., regarding any and all of the following programs:
-“Countering Violent Extremism” (CVE)
-“Preventing Violent Extremism” (PVE)
-“Black Identity Extremism” (BIE)
-“Targeted Violence and Terrorism Prevention” (TVTP)
-“Youth and Police Initiative Plus” (YPIP)
-“Youth and Police Initiative” (YPI)
-“New Freedoms Intervention”
-“Developing Resilience to Violent Extremism”
-"Empower Peace"
-"Online4Good"
[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record fulfillment)]

3) Any and all records or documents created with/by, mentioning, provided by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs, reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the domain “@adl.org” including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “osegal@adl.org”), presentations, slides, transactions, training materials, consultations, curricula, etc., regarding the PLANNING FOR and/or DEVELOPMENT of any and all of the following programs:
-“Countering Violent Extremism” (CVE)
-“Preventing Violent Extremism” (PVE)
-“Black Identity Extremism” (BIE)
-“Targeted Violence and Terrorism Prevention” (TVTP)
-“Youth and Police Initiative Plus” (YPIP)
-“Youth and Police Initiative” (YPI)
-“New Freedoms Intervention”
-“Developing Resilience to Violent Extremism”
-"Empower Peace"
-"Online4Good"
[from January 1st, 2013 to December 31st, 2016]

4) Any and all correspondences with the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) (email addresses with the domain “@adl.org”, including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “osegal@adl.org”) also addressed to, or mentioning, cc’ing, or bcc’ing any and all of the following INDIVIDUALS or ORGANIZATIONS:
“Police Foundation”; “North American Family Institute” (NAFI); “Somali Community and Cultural Association” (SCCA); “Slonky”; “Boston Children’s Hospital”; “Empower Peace”; “Parents for Peace”; “Deeqo Jibril”; “James Bueerman”; “Jane Dorsey”; “Frank Straub”; “Jay Paris”; “William B. Evans”; “Carmen M. Ortiz”; “Brandy Donini-Melanson”; “Jennifer Maconochie”; “Julie Grieco”; “Rebecca Benson”; “Joyce Iwashita”; “Brett Cowell”; “Lorena Sobhi”; “Jeffrey Brownell”; “Patrick McMurray”; “Kevin Stanton”; “Daniel Bennett”; “Rhiana Kohl”; and "Richard Rendon"
[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record fulfillment)]

5) Any and all records or documents created with/by, mentioning, provided by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs, reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the domain “@adl.org”, including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “osegal@adl.org”), presentations, slides, transactions, training materials, consultations, curricula, etc., regarding DATA or INFORMATION SHARING, including but not limited to data or information about:
-“hate”
-“hate speech”
-“hate crimes”
-“terrorism”
-“extremism”
-“violent extremism”
-“radicalization”
-“incitement”
[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record fulfillment)]

6) Any and all correspondences with the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) (email addresses with the domain “@adl.org”, including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “osegal@adl.org”) with any and all of the KEYWORDS/SEARCH TERMS:
“violent extremism”; “Israel”; “Israel/Palestine”; “Palestine”; "Palestinian"; “radicalization”; “deradicalization”; “Preventing Violent Extremism”; “PVE”; “Countering Violent Extremism”; “CVE”; “BDS"; ; “lone wolf”; “hate speech”; “hate crime”; “parental engagement”; “parent engagement”; “risk factor”; “indicator”; “interfaith”; "curriculum"; “incitement”; "curricula"; “threat analysis”; "threat assessment"; “risk assessment”; “intervention”; "prevention; “Islam”; “Muslim”; “gang”; “anti-gang”; “scenario-based”; “community resilience”; “refugee”; “jihad”; “jihadi”; “jihadist”; “violence prevention”; “convert”; “trusted community partners”; “mental health”; “substance abuse”; "trafficking"; "sex trafficking"; “suicide”; “bullying”; “radical views”; “extremist”; “extremism”; “violent extremist”; “safe spaces”; “dialog promotion”; “aggression”; “new Muslim”; “prison”; “reentry”; “re-entry”; “counseling”; “counselor”; "counsel”; “clinic”; “mentor”; “mentorship”; “terrorism”; “terrorist”; “crisis intervention”; “counter-narrative”; “anti-Semitism”; “antisemitism”; “Zionism”; “Zionist”; “anti-Zionism”; "anti-Zionist”; “anti-Israel”; “Incidence Response”; “Incident Response”; “prison dawah”; “terrorism ideologies”; “warning signs”; “civil rights”; “civil liberties”; “community education”; “train-the-trainer”; “ISIS”; “Islamic State”; “al-Qaeda”; “Islamist”; “cartel”; “migrant”; “community expert”; “material support”; “recruitment”; “harassment”; “hotline”; “anti-bullying”; “online safety”; “early prevention”; “Somali”; “Somalia”; “Al Shabaab”; “Roxbury”; “Al Shabab”; “trust-building”; “ideology-based”; “community liaison”; “maximum security”; “displaced aggression”; “displacement of aggression”; “Department Disciplinary Unit”; “outpatient”; “behavioral health”; “community-based treatment”; “Boston Marathon”; “community resilience”; “information sharing”; “peer-to-peer”; “ case management”; “DDU”; “administrative segregation”; “gang affiliation”; “recidivism”; “COMPAS”; “Orientation & Motivational Enhancement”; “Community Orientation”; “New Freedom”; “A. R. Phoenix Resources, Inc.”; “outpatient behavioral health treatment”; “pro-social”; “peer mentoring”; “contingency management”; "Online4Good"
[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record fulfillment)]

For the purposes of this request, “records” includes but is not limited to any paper or electronic information, reports, evaluations, memoranda, correspondence, letters, emails, charts, graphs, flyers, meeting agendas and minutes, training materials, diagrams, forms, DVDs, tapes, CDs, notes or other similar materials. If the requested records are stored in electronic format, we ask that they be produced in electronic format.

For the purposes of this request, “correspondences” includes but is not limited to any and all letters, emails, call transcriptions, meeting notes, and any and all other forms of paper and electronic communications sent to, received from, cc’ing and bcc’ing the Anti-Defamation League and any member of the Anti-Defamation League. If the requested records are stored in electronic format, we ask that they be produced in electronic format.

I also request that, if appropriate, fees be waived as we believe this request is in the public interest, as suggested but not stipulated by the recommendations of the Massachusetts Supervisor of Public Records. The requested documents will be made available to the general public free of charge as part of the public information service at MuckRock.com, processed by a representative of the news media/press and is made in the process of news gathering and not for commercial usage.

I expect the request to be filled in an accessible format, including for screen readers, which provide text-to-speech for persons unable to read print. Files that are not accessible to screen readers include, for example, .pdf image files as well as physical documents.

In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. I would prefer the request filled electronically, by e-mail attachment if available or CD-ROM if not.

Thank you in advance for your anticipated cooperation in this matter. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 10 business days, as the statute requires.

Sincerely,

Jonathan Brown

From: Boston Public Schools

BOSTON PUBLIC SCHOOLS
OFFICE OF LEGAL ADVISOR

Martin J. Walsh, Mayor

October 21, 2020

Jonathan Brown

Muckrock.com

Re: August 6, 2020 Public Records Requests;

Dear Jonathan:

Boston Public Schools (“BPS”) has received your August 6, 2020 public
records requests. This response applies only to records that exist and are
in the custody of the City. See A Guide to the Massachusetts Public
Records Law, p. 32, n.115. It is expected that a custodian of records must
use her superior knowledge of her records with respect to responses to
public records requests. 950 CMR 32.04(5). Below, please find your
specific requests and BPS’s responses in blue.

1) Any and all records or documents created with, mentioning, provided
by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including
but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs,
reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the
domain “@adl.org” including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “
rtrestan@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “osegal@adl.org”),
presentations, slides, transactions, training materials, consultations,
curricula, etc., for the sake of preventing:

-“violent extremism”

-“terrorism”

-“radicalization”

-“incitement”

-“hate speech”

-“hate crimes”

[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record
fulfillment)]

2) Any and all records or documents created with/by, mentioning, provided
by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including
but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs,
reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the
domain “@adl.org” including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “
rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “
osegal@adl.org”), presentations, slides, transactions, training materials,
consultations, curricula, etc., regarding any and all of the following
programs:

-“Countering Violent Extremism” (CVE)

-“Preventing Violent Extremism” (PVE)

-“Black Identity Extremism” (BIE)

-“Targeted Violence and Terrorism Prevention” (TVTP)

-“Youth and Police Initiative Plus” (YPIP)

-“Youth and Police Initiative” (YPI)

-“New Freedoms Intervention”

-“Developing Resilience to Violent Extremism”

-"Empower Peace"

-"Online4Good"

[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record
fulfillment)]

3) Any and all records or documents created with/by, mentioning, provided
by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including
but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs,
reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the
domain “@adl.org” including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “
rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “
osegal@adl.org”), presentations, slides, transactions, training materials,
consultations, curricula, etc., regarding the PLANNING FOR and/or
DEVELOPMENT of any and all of the following programs:

-“Countering Violent Extremism” (CVE)

-“Preventing Violent Extremism” (PVE)

-“Black Identity Extremism” (BIE)

-“Targeted Violence and Terrorism Prevention” (TVTP)

-“Youth and Police Initiative Plus” (YPIP)

-“Youth and Police Initiative” (YPI)

-“New Freedoms Intervention”

-“Developing Resilience to Violent Extremism”

-"Empower Peace"

-"Online4Good"

[from January 1st, 2013 to December 31st, 2016]

4) Any and all correspondences with the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) (email
addresses with the domain “@adl.org”, including but not limited to “
mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org",
and “osegal@adl.org”) also addressed to, or mentioning, cc’ing, or bcc’ing
any and all of the following INDIVIDUALS or ORGANIZATIONS:

“Police Foundation”; “North American Family Institute” (NAFI); “Somali
Community and Cultural Association” (SCCA); “Slonky”; “Boston Children’s
Hospital”; “Empower Peace”; “Parents for Peace”; “Deeqo Jibril”; “James
Bueerman”; “Jane Dorsey”; “Frank Straub”; “Jay Paris”; “William B. Evans”;
“Carmen M. Ortiz”; “Brandy Donini-Melanson”; “Jennifer Maconochie”; “Julie
Grieco”; “Rebecca Benson”; “Joyce Iwashita”; “Brett Cowell”; “Lorena
Sobhi”; “Jeffrey Brownell”; “Patrick McMurray”; “Kevin Stanton”; “Daniel
Bennett”; “Rhiana Kohl”; and "Richard Rendon"

[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record
fulfillment)]

5) Any and all records or documents created with/by, mentioning, provided
by/to, or otherwise involving the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) including
but not limited to grants, scholarships, fellowships, contracts, MOUs,
reports, emails (to, from, cc’ing, or bcc’ing email addresses with the
domain “@adl.org”, including but not limited to “mgarlick@adl.org”, “
rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org", and “
osegal@adl.org”), presentations, slides, transactions, training materials,
consultations, curricula, etc., regarding DATA or INFORMATION SHARING,
including but not limited to data or information about:

-“hate”

-“hate speech”

-“hate crimes”

-“terrorism”

-“extremism”

-“violent extremism”

-“radicalization”

-“incitement”

[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record
fulfillment)]

6) Any and all correspondences with the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) (email
addresses with the domain “@adl.org”, including but not limited to “
mgarlick@adl.org”, “rtrestan@adl.org”, “ejarvis@adl.org”, "pfogelman@adl.org",
and “osegal@adl.org”) with any and all of the KEYWORDS/SEARCH TERMS:

“violent extremism”; “Israel”; “Israel/Palestine”; “Palestine”;
"Palestinian"; “radicalization”; “deradicalization”; “Preventing Violent
Extremism”; “PVE”; “Countering Violent Extremism”; “CVE”; “BDS"; ; “lone
wolf”; “hate speech”; “hate crime”; “parental engagement”; “parent
engagement”; “risk factor”; “indicator”; “interfaith”; "curriculum";
“incitement”; "curricula"; “threat analysis”; "threat assessment"; “risk
assessment”; “intervention”; "prevention; “Islam”; “Muslim”; “gang”;
“anti-gang”; “scenario-based”; “community resilience”; “refugee”; “jihad”;
“jihadi”; “jihadist”; “violence prevention”; “convert”; “trusted community
partners”; “mental health”; “substance abuse”; "trafficking"; "sex
trafficking"; “suicide”; “bullying”; “radical views”; “extremist”;
“extremism”; “violent extremist”; “safe spaces”; “dialog promotion”;
“aggression”; “new Muslim”; “prison”; “reentry”; “re-entry”; “counseling”;
“counselor”; "counsel”; “clinic”; “mentor”; “mentorship”; “terrorism”;
“terrorist”; “crisis intervention”; “counter-narrative”; “anti-Semitism”;
“antisemitism”; “Zionism”; “Zionist”; “anti-Zionism”; "anti-Zionist”;
“anti-Israel”; “Incidence Response”; “Incident Response”; “prison dawah”;
“terrorism ideologies”; “warning signs”; “civil rights”; “civil liberties”;
“community education”; “train-the-trainer”; “ISIS”; “Islamic State”;
“al-Qaeda”; “Islamist”; “cartel”; “migrant”; “community expert”; “material
support”; “recruitment”; “harassment”; “hotline”; “anti-bullying”; “online
safety”; “early prevention”; “Somali”; “Somalia”; “Al Shabaab”; “Roxbury”;
“Al Shabab”; “trust-building”; “ideology-based”; “community liaison”;
“maximum security”; “displaced aggression”; “displacement of aggression”;
“Department Disciplinary Unit”; “outpatient”; “behavioral health”;
“community-based treatment”; “Boston Marathon”; “community resilience”;
“information sharing”; “peer-to-peer”; “ case management”; “DDU”;
“administrative segregation”; “gang affiliation”; “recidivism”; “COMPAS”;
“Orientation & Motivational Enhancement”; “Community Orientation”; “New
Freedom”; “A. R. Phoenix Resources, Inc.”; “outpatient behavioral health
treatment”; “pro-social”; “peer mentoring”; “contingency management”;
"Online4Good"

[from January 1st, 2015 to August 5th, 2020 (or most current date of record
fulfillment)]

For the purposes of this request, “records” includes but is not limited to
any paper or electronic information, reports, evaluations, memoranda,
correspondence, letters, emails, charts, graphs, flyers, meeting agendas
and minutes, training materials, diagrams, forms, DVDs, tapes, CDs, notes
or other similar materials. If the requested records are stored in
electronic format, we ask that they be produced in electronic format.

For the purposes of this request, “correspondences” includes but is not
limited to any and all letters, emails, call transcriptions, meeting notes,
and any and all other forms of paper and electronic communications sent to,
received from, cc’ing and bcc’ing the Anti-Defamation League and any member
of the Anti-Defamation League. If the requested records are stored in
electronic format, we ask that they be produced in electronic format.

Records responsive to your request are available electronically via the
Records Center. Please log on to GovQA to access these records. They are
also attached to this email.

Conclusion

You may appeal this response to the Supervisor of Records in the Office of
the Secretary of the Commonwealth. G.L. c. 66, § 10A (c); G.L. c. 66, §
10(b)(ix); 950 CMR 32.08; 950 CMR 32.08(1)(h) (in petitioning the
Supervisor, the requester shall provide a copy of such petition to the
records access officer associated with such petition). You may also appeal
to the Superior Court. 950 CMR 32.06(3)(c).

Sincerely,

Catherine Lizotte

Legal Advisor
(617) 635-9250

--
Catherine Lizotte
Legal Advisor

Office of the Legal Advisor | Boston Public Schools

2300 Washington Street, Boston MA 02119

clizotte@bostonpublicschools.org| 617-635-9250

*The information contained in this electronic transmission (“e-mail”),
including any attachment (“Information”), may be confidential or otherwise
exempt from disclosure. It is for the addressee only. This Information may
be privileged and confidential attorney work-product or a privileged and
confidential attorney-client communication. The Information may also be
deliberative in nature. As such, it is for internal use only. If you have
received this e-mail by mistake, please notify the sender and delete it
from your system. Please do not copy or forward it. Thank you for your
cooperation.*

Files

pages

Close